WoodNet Forums View Today's Active Woodworking Topics
View All Today's Active Topics
Woodsmith Shop: FREE Plans, Info, and Video Tips!

Active >> Woodworking

Pages: 1 | 2 | 3 | Next | (show all)
Steve N
Member

Registered: 09/28/07
Posts: 3639
Loc: CinDay
Talk about ways to cut down sheet goods
      #4201714 - 03/09/09 10:42 AM

As stated in the title "Talk about ways to cut down sheet goods" Add to it, drop pics, share experiences, thoughts, etc. Maybe a learning tool for the Noobs, or possibly a thought or 3 for anyone looking into this subject.

A recent thread about The newest track saws to come to market, the DeWalt to go up against the tested Festool, well it got off course from just that topic, but it opened a bit about other ways for someone to cut down sheet goods for projects.

Thread

From that thread I got to thinking a post of many ways to skin a cat, and at a bunch of different price points. Lets face it not everyone here has the same budget for tool/toy expenditure.


Second from that, why do you need a guide at all? Is it to cut down sheet goods to smaller, more manageable sizes, then take them to the TS for final trimming? If so do we need a guide? Couldn`t we just make a line, snap chalk, and just cut freehand to a size appx 1/4 over what we need. Ok point taken, we need/want a fresh, straight edge to put against the TS`s fence to then cut the panel square and accurate, so some guide is a good thing, yes???

First on the track saws. Glen Huey has a nice, albeit undecided review of the 3 track saws: Festool, DeWalt, Makita in the most recent Popular Woodworking (#175 April 2009). His end point is they all make appx the same cuts, and it will be features that are available on each model, and brand name favoritism that will make the buying decision for each individual. This method works as a quick, easy way to cut down sheet goods, and can be used on solid materials too, though it seems sheet goods is what most people talk about them for. I tried the new DeWalt last fall, and liked it a bunch, my time before that with a Festool always left me feeling it was awkward? Go figure. Until reading the article in Pop WW I wasn`t aware Makita was in the race. Look for appx $500.00 for the saw and a track of somewhere around 50" for all three. With all 3 other accessories are available. Some woodworkers with limited space are opting out of a TS and just using these guided saws. If so $500.00 for a VERY accurate, and portable TS is a steal. Many here with both have voiced they will also keep their TS.

Another store bough guide was mentioned, the ez system. Several here posted how happy they are with this middle priced alternative to the track saws, which actually give you a saw in the appx $500.00 price. The EZ is just a track guide that you mount your CS onto, and supposedly it becomes a Festool wannabe. I cannot add to the list of positive reviewers. I`ve not owned one, but a friend of mine bought one when they first hit market, and his thoughts are it was, and still is his worst expenditure of funds on a woodworking tool, item, jig, etc etc. I played with it a few times , and my thought was it had a lot more flex in it than I liked, (whimpy), and this added to the problem, while taking it from the box? shipping container, it had bent, due to how lightweight it was. My friend grew tired of playing with it, pitched it, and for a while just went back to basics, until he bought a Festool a few years ago. He`s been real happy with it`s performance. Now that said, maybe this EZ deal has been re-worked, re-made. I don`t know, but perusing the site I`m just left feeling it`s a lot more than the other fixes I`m about to show, and I don`t know if it`s much faster for the money.

"$158.95 The SGS-50 is the answer to the difficult cross cuts and trimming cuts up to 50"

through


"$471.95 For the extra long straight line rip cuts and joining long boards without the need of expensive equipment". Hmmmmm it cuts up to 200", but it doesn`t come with a saw, so wondering which expensive equipment you don`t need


Next in line, also store bought, and getting into my price structure, (even better pricing if you score them hardly used at auction , of course same could be said off all shown here)

Several to choose from, most seem very similar. As it`s worked out the ones I got are Pro Grip line found here


What I`ll refer to as the Blue line, found Rockler, and I think WoodCraft


Boomers

Possibly others exist, I`m not aware of them, but it seems to be a big market, cutting guides, edge guides, etc. What is similar here is they all clamp to the workpiece, all have at least one t-track type groove to mount other clamps, jigs and fixtures to, and offer a raised edge to use as a cutting guide, something to run a CS, router, jigsaw against. These clamps also offer a growing line of add ons that make them more self squaring, easier to align your saws blade to where you want to cut, sleds that run in the aforementioned t slots, and much more.

Never one to keep opinions to myself I`ll state I`ve toyed with the one sled type I`ve seen actually attached at a WW show. I think they keep them unattached because attached you see first hand how much slop and wiggle is found in between a t-track, and the toilet bolt that is running inside the t track. This means a truly straight line with the sled is less possible than just running your tool alongside the clamp itself. However if you are not able to keep the tool FIRMLY against the side of the clamp, well, a little wobble might be a good thing for you. You know your own abilities, buy accordingly.

From there they have other guides to help square the clamp to the plywood it`s being clamped to, and also a cut guide that once cut through gives you a reference point in setting the clamp for future cuts.

I`m not sure here, as all I`m using are the pro grip variety, they come with 2 tap holes in the clamp heads on the clamp already, not sure if this carries over to blue, and Boomer, but I`m betting they might also have them. If you do have the 2 holes. Roll your own self aligners, and cut guides all in one.




If it does all you need are screws and some easy to make pieces. Whatever size you like, just make sure they are uniform thickness, or you will be making angled cuts, and then drill for size to match the 2 holes. Make sure to allow enough size to the right of the clamp for what you need to make a cut through the wood. Counterbore the holes so the screw heads are not sticking out.




cut guide/squaring edge shown attached






Ready to make 1st cut through. Placing your CS firmly against the clamps edge just start making your cut. After the first cut you now have a quick set guide to show you where to place the clamp. Just line up the edge of the cut guide up to your line to mark where you want to cut, and clamp. Makes things quick, easy and accurate, especially so if just making fast cuts to break down sheet goods for finish cuts on the TS. If you want to use these cuts as finish cuts, do your sawing on top of a thick piece of pink foam insulation, and remember to apply a line of blue painters/quick release tape over the top side of the cut line. Doing this will give you a splinter free edge. I suggest using a good quality plywood/veneer cutting blade on your CS for best cuts. Also make sure after clamping to check both ends of the clamp to make sure your cut IS going to be on the money. This last just needed if you do NOT plan to make final cuts on TS.





Don`t have a pro grip, or blue line type clamp, Boomer anyone? It`s ok, looking at your local scrap yard might net you some nice bar stock, comes in Aluminum, and mild steel. That and a couple of clamps can make an accurate cutting guide.




Comes in many lengths, widths and thicknesses.





Don`t want to spend so much $$$$, but you say you have some scrap ply, and a few good straight boards.





Whew, yeah I`m wordy, sorry.

Ok add on folks, hope the pics help anyone with the clamp guides to make their own cut guides, and squaring edges. If you`re an EZ system fan, sorry it was a call made long ago, and I`ve not seen wording to change my thoughts about the original model on the website, so original model thoughts stand because they are about the ez system I know.

--------------------
Worst thing they can do is cook ya and eat ya

Steve


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Phydeaux
Superficially Profound

Registered: 02/12/06
Posts: 2238
Loc: New Hampshire
Re: Talk about ways to cut down sheet goods new [Re: Steve N]
      #4201730 - 03/09/09 10:48 AM

I do fine with four saw horses, a 35-year old Skil saw and a 100", 2-piece aluminum straight edge of the same vintage. I'm sure there are some new gadgets that would help, but I find I'd be doing myself enough of a favor if I'd just cut a block of wood to help me set the spacing right from straight edge to blade. Lazy and cheap as I am what I've got works well enough I haven't made that little gesture.

Depends a lot on how much extra convenience you want to pay for.

--------------------
Phydeaux


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Allen
Honored Veteran

Registered: 03/17/01
Posts: 4834
Loc: IL
Re: Talk about ways to cut down sheet goods new [Re: Steve N]
      #4201773 - 03/09/09 11:12 AM

I just use two saw horses side by side. Both have a strip of wood across the bottom of two legs. This lets me rest a full sheet on edge supported on the side of the horses. A straight edge and a PC Saw Boss breaks it down into what ever size I need with out any trouble.

Al

--------------------
Handle every stressful situation like a dog. If you can't eat it or hump it, wizz on it and walk away.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
RokJok
Member

Registered: 09/11/05
Posts: 1782
Loc: Rainy side of the Cascade Mtns
Re: Talk about ways to cut down sheet goods new [Re: Steve N]
      #4201821 - 03/09/09 11:37 AM

I lay 2x4's on the floor (2-3 on each side of the cut line) with the sheet good on top of them. I double-check my blade depth to insure I don't try cutting the concrete floor beneath the 2x4's.

I've heard from a cabinetmaker I respect, but haven't tried yet, using a 2" thick sheet of insulation foam (blue- or pink-board from the Borg) laid on the floor with the sheet good on top. Since you can safely cut into the foam without hurting the saw blade and its light density doesn't appreciably bog down the cutting, it doesn't matter how you toss the sheet good onto the foam sheet. That saves sliding around the 2x4's of my method to insure the cut line falls between the 2x's to keep the cutting easy.

Otherwise, your final drawing of a DIY zero-clearance straight-edge guide is IMHO the way to go. As noted, initially make the base wider than the circular saw's blade-to-edge-of-base-plate distance so the first time the saw passes over the jig you cut the base to the exact offset of that distance.

For crosscutting sheet goods I have 50" Rockler clamping guides I pick up when they are on sale.

--------------------
"For true creativity, we have to think beyond our tools." - MsNomer

"A request is not stupid if it is written on the back of a big enough check." - paraphrase of DaveD


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
rhino
Member

Registered: 09/30/05
Posts: 3406
Loc: Cincinnati, OH
Re: Talk about ways to cut down sheet goods new [Re: Steve N]
      #4201854 - 03/09/09 11:53 AM

Steve N

Thanks for getting this ball rolling. I'm sure there are lots of opinions on this topic, and lots of ways to get it done.

For me, I used the EZ system to break down the sheet goods for my kitchen cabinets. A fresh freud Diablo, and I had great edges for banding etc. I don't trust my hand to be flush and square against a straight edge for a long cut, and really appreciate the guided rails, but that's just me.

I used the EZ just this weekend to cut the ends off of a table top. Everyting came up square, and the edges were nice and crisp.

When I got my EZ, the only other option was festool. I think the market is now a bit more populated, and it will be interesting to see how things end up.

--------------------
Tools that are no good require greater skill.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
RolHammer
The Inquisitor

Registered: 10/13/07
Posts: 3868
Loc: Wedged between SK & BC
Re: Talk about ways to cut down sheet goods new [Re: Steve N]
      #4201939 - 03/09/09 12:31 PM

Steve-o! Good on ya for getting the balling rolling on this.

Up til recently, I'd lay down the four sheets of styrofoam insulation I'd sized for just such occasions (if you go this route and do much work with BB, ensure you can accomodate 5'x5' stock too - experience talking here). Then, I'd use my edge guide I got from Busy Bee Tools (Canada's Grizzly) - looks pretty much identical to the Boomer Classic from MLCS - and my CS. After checking that I'm only juuust cutting into the styrofoam, I'd make the cuts. If required, a trip to the TS would square things up or break them down further.

Now, though, I have an Excalibur 50-SLT40 sliding table mounted on my TS.

I'd also awhile back bought the Shop Built Panel Saw plans and kit from Rockler, which I still plan on building. Refinements to the design found online here and elsewhere will allow the carriage to translate vertically as well as horizonally. It also can house a CS as well as router - making it a must-build in my mind.

--------------------
You can't teach laziness. You either have it or you...<yawn>...ah, whatever...

Roland


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Steve N
Member

Registered: 09/28/07
Posts: 3639
Loc: CinDay
Re: Talk about ways to cut down sheet goods new [Re: RokJok]
      #4201981 - 03/09/09 12:46 PM

RokJok using a good quality blade, the foam under, and a piece of blue painters tape on top of the ply, you`ll enjoy a cut as crisp as one made with a Festool, and think of all the $$$$ still in your pocket.

I think primarily it comes down to how many sheets of ply ya cut into a week, month, year. If it`s consistently a lot, then spending $500 for a festool or one of the others is appropriate spending IMHO. If you just cut a sheet a month even, which I`m guessing, but figure it more than 95% who come here will cut, then a much less costly, however more time consuming method is in order.

As always my warped, weird, view of the world.

--------------------
Worst thing they can do is cook ya and eat ya

Steve


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
mikefm101
Member

Registered: 11/10/04
Posts: 204
Loc: Lunenburg, MA
Re: Talk about ways to cut down sheet goods new [Re: Steve N]
      #4201993 - 03/09/09 12:51 PM

I have my plywood dealer cut it close, finish at home.

If need be I'll lay a sheet across my TS and outfeed table and then use a circular saw to cut in the gap between the saw and the table. Works very well.

I made two 2x3 cutting frames years ago I used to use a bunch, but not so much since the outfeed table was made.

As long as I leave a factory edge as a reference I am good. If in th emiddle the lumberyard cuts it down with a good enough reference edge to cut final parts from.

Mike


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
RolHammer
The Inquisitor

Registered: 10/13/07
Posts: 3868
Loc: Wedged between SK & BC
Re: Talk about ways to cut down sheet goods new [Re: Steve N]
      #4202060 - 03/09/09 01:27 PM

Oh yes, I forgot to add: These tracksaws? Insane! For the price, all you get is the ability to rip accurately across 50". Big whoopdeedoo, I say. The styrofoam + edge guide + CS solution does 99% of that for < 30% of the price.

I must admit to being mystified at WTF all the hubbub is about these track saws. For the price of these things, you can buy a large, flexible accessory that does everything these things can do and more. That, and at their price, you're about 1/3 to 1/4 of the way to a dedicated, commercial panel saw (see previous sentence for further ranting to complete this sentence).

Well, I guess if one needs accurate, portable capability to bring to a jobsite, then these sorts of things make some sense. Otherwise, meh.

YMMV though.

--------------------
You can't teach laziness. You either have it or you...<yawn>...ah, whatever...

Roland


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
daveferg
member

Registered: 02/19/02
Posts: 26733
Loc: Cloverdale, CA, USA
Re: Talk about ways to cut down sheet goods new [Re: mikefm101]
      #4202068 - 03/09/09 01:30 PM

I think it's like anything else. Someone is always going to come out with something fanicer and more expensive to do a job that has been done for years with minimal investment in tools.

First---after I moved out of home after school, my first ww'ing was done with a skill saw and straight edge, so there's a lot you can do with care and planing.

I also started off with an old circ. saw (Craftsman) and a two-piece straight edge (which I still have because it's 8 ft. long. Granted, these take a little time to check and re-check for square. I just make it a rule, whenever possible, to have at least one factory edge per piece of cut stock, because mistakes will happen.

I had two problems with that simple system----the time to square up the guide with the stock, and that hold down clamps would get in the way fo fe circular saw.

Now, while Fesstool and others have off set guides set to the width of the sole plate, it is also extremely easy to make one with a couple long straight pieces. This also has the advantage of letting the clamps sit out past the saw body so you don't get hung up. I also like this type of guide in that it easily adapts to adding a square cross-piece at one end. This saves a load of time.

--------------------
Dave


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Pages: 1 | 2 | 3 | Next | (show all)
PlansNOW: Get Project Plans from Woodsmith Magazine


Extra information
13 registered and 10 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  Gene P, GGaippe, Vince, WoodNet Manager, K. L, McReynolds, fivestring©™±, thooks, EightFingers, Joe Fisher, AnthonyYak, barnowl, Ruffturn®, meackerman, Bibliophile 13, Blacky's Boy, Grainraiser 

Print Thread

Forum Permissions
      You cannot start new topics
      You cannot reply to topics
      HTML is disabled
      UBBCode is enabled

Thread views: 1983

Jump to

Contact Us | Contact the Moderators | Privacy Policy WoodNet Forums | WoodNet

*
UBB.threads™ 6.4.4