WoodNet Forums View Today's Active Woodworking Topics
View All Today's Active Topics
Complete Back Issue Library

Active >> Woodworking Hand Tools

MarvW
Member

Registered: 08/27/07
Posts: 2507
Loc: Northern California
Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project
      03/28/12 11:54 AM

Hi Joss,

From a saw makers standpoint, they need to document what their final design is so it can be duplicated in a production mode. They design the handle and how it is located on the saw plate as to how they feel it gives the best performance results. If what Dom has done in his CAD drawings, will prove to be satisfactory to him, he now has a document that he can use for future saws, saws that will perform the same. When we pick up saws made from various saw makers, grasp the hand grip, extend the saw to arms length, the actual hang can be compared. One saw might hang lower at the toe end than another. Both saws will perhaps perform quite well, even though one might feel more comfortable to a user than the other. The so called "proper" or "correct" way to create a certain hang for saws in general, falls within quite a range of acceptance and feasibility. With any tool, there will be design limits for every aspect of the tool. Think of any aspect of a saw, then picture in your mind where you think the outer limits are. Beyond those limits will be an area that makes the saw non-functional. Within those limits will be a "sweet" spot. And so it is with locating a handle on a saw plate. When approaching the limits the saw will still be functional, but many users will notice it and may search for a saw that feels and functions more to their liking. As I use the various saws that I have in my saw till, I can definitely feel distinct differences from one saw to another. They all cut wood, but with a little different feel.

--------------------
Catchalater,
Marv


I did then what I knew how to do. Now that I know better, I do better.”
― Maya Angelou

I'm working toward my PHD. (Projects Half Done)

Post Extras Print Post   Remind Me!     Notify Moderator

Entire thread
Subject Posted by Posted on
* Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project Blacky's Boy 03/26/12 07:43 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project Window Guy   04/02/12 10:17 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates Blacky's BoyModerator   04/02/12 09:26 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates Blacky's BoyModerator   04/03/12 07:41 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The handles Blacky's BoyModerator   04/04/12 08:03 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The handles Blacky's BoyModerator   04/06/12 08:48 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The handles MarvW   04/07/12 10:34 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The handles mbole   03/06/13 07:22 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The handles Tony Z   03/06/13 07:28 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The handles KlausK.   04/07/12 12:31 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The handles Isaac S   04/07/12 07:16 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The handles Window Guy   04/07/12 07:11 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The handles Tony Z   04/07/12 06:28 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The handles KlausK.   04/07/12 07:05 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The handles mongo   04/06/12 09:33 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The handles Brian K   04/06/12 10:16 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The handles Brian K   04/06/12 09:12 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The handles BaileyNo5   04/04/12 09:18 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The handles Corneel   04/04/12 11:59 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The handles Blacky's BoyModerator   04/05/12 06:55 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The handles Window Guy   04/05/12 10:41 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The handles dpmohne   04/05/12 02:36 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The handles Window Guy   04/06/12 07:51 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The handles Blacky's BoyModerator   04/05/12 12:00 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The handles Window Guy   04/05/12 12:55 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The handles Brian K   04/05/12 06:46 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The handles Window Guy   04/06/12 07:52 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The handles Brian K   04/05/12 10:22 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The handles Blacky's BoyModerator   04/05/12 10:26 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The handles Brian K   04/05/12 10:29 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The handles RonB1957   04/04/12 08:58 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates Craig D   04/03/12 02:26 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates Blacky's BoyModerator   04/03/12 02:55 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates Craig D   04/03/12 04:42 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates MarvW   04/02/12 11:02 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates Blacky's BoyModerator   04/02/12 12:11 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates MarvW   04/02/12 12:38 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates Blacky's BoyModerator   04/02/12 01:19 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates MarvW   04/02/12 02:08 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates Tony Z   04/02/12 02:37 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates MarvW   04/02/12 04:20 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates Tony Z   04/02/12 04:29 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates RonB1957   04/02/12 10:03 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates MarvW   04/03/12 09:05 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates Blacky's BoyModerator   04/03/12 09:33 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates Brian K   04/03/12 10:28 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates MarvW   04/03/12 09:54 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates nazard   04/03/12 06:06 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates Blacky's BoyModerator   04/04/12 07:03 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates RonB1957   04/02/12 02:35 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates Tony Z   04/02/12 01:40 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates AHill   04/02/12 11:23 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates Erik M   04/02/12 10:17 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates JustinTyson   04/02/12 10:23 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates Blacky's BoyModerator   04/02/12 10:53 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates jossimbyr   04/02/12 03:00 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates Blacky's BoyModerator   04/02/12 03:24 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates jossimbyr   04/03/12 03:50 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates Blacky's BoyModerator   04/04/12 12:31 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates Window Guy   04/05/12 05:46 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates jossimbyr   04/04/12 12:38 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates Blacky's BoyModerator   04/04/12 01:11 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates jossimbyr   04/04/12 03:11 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project: The saw plates Tony Z   04/02/12 03:56 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project Jim Shaver   03/28/12 12:20 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project Blacky's BoyModerator   03/28/12 12:45 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project beginningwoodworker   03/27/12 08:38 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project joemac   03/26/12 03:47 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project BaileyNo5   03/26/12 03:42 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project jossimbyr   03/26/12 09:29 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project Blacky's BoyModerator   03/26/12 10:13 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project pjm   03/27/12 10:27 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project Blacky's BoyModerator   03/27/12 10:51 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project MarvW   03/27/12 11:09 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project jossimbyr   03/27/12 01:09 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project MarvW   03/27/12 03:57 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project jossimbyr   03/28/12 10:58 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project MarvW   03/28/12 11:54 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project jossimbyr   03/28/12 03:42 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project TobyC   03/27/12 02:25 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project Steve Friedman   03/27/12 01:23 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project Steve Friedman   03/26/12 10:23 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project Blacky's BoyModerator   03/26/12 10:34 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project TobyC   03/27/12 03:45 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project Bozz   03/26/12 03:51 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project Corneel   03/27/12 02:26 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project Blacky's BoyModerator   03/27/12 07:02 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project ZachDillinger   03/27/12 09:37 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project Blacky's BoyModerator   03/27/12 09:42 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project ZachDillinger   03/27/12 09:46 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project Blacky's BoyModerator   03/27/12 11:48 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project Isaac S   03/28/12 09:11 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project Blacky's BoyModerator   03/28/12 09:13 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project Isaac S   03/28/12 09:33 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project Window Guy   04/02/12 10:19 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project Blacky's BoyModerator   03/28/12 10:21 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project MarvW   03/28/12 09:40 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project KlausK.   03/27/12 03:05 PM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project Corneel   03/27/12 07:27 AM
. * Re: Big Ripsaw and Crosscut saw project Timberwolf   03/26/12 07:48 AM

Extra information
1 registered and 15 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  WoodNet Manager, Gene P, Vince, K. L, McReynolds, thooks, EightFingers, fivestring©™±, Joe Fisher, barnowl, Ruffturn®, meackerman, Bibliophile 13, Blacky's Boy, Grainraiser, blackhat 



Forum Permissions
      You cannot start new topics
      You cannot reply to topics
      HTML is disabled
      UBBCode is enabled

Thread views: 14430

Jump to

Contact Us | Contact the Moderators | Privacy Policy WoodNet Forums | WoodNet

*
UBB.threads™ 6.4.4