WoodNet Forums View Today's Active Woodworking Topics
View All Today's Active Topics
Complete Back Issue Library

Active >> Woodworking Hand Tools

CStanford
Member

Registered: 07/28/05
Posts: 1108
Re: A2 Sharpening Question
      07/23/12 07:07 AM

2+2 doesn't equal 5. The media will impart what it will impart where it's rubbed. There's no way around it.

One can abrade more steel (i.e. go 'deeper') as far down the back of the cutter as one would care to go (and indeed one will over time). This is usually pretty far because it's easier to register more cutter on the stone when lapping the back. Doing this in a restricted area is a bit of a timesaver at best, IMO (ignoring Derek's assertion that the back bevel acts as some sort of barrier for wear moving down the back).

For my slapdash ways keeping up with a back bevel would just be another opportunity for something to go wrong, jigged with a ruler or not. And as previously mentioned, I'm gettin' there anyway. Can't avoid polishing down the back even if I wanted to. I'm just letting nature take its course, letting the stone do what it wants to do.

I'm sure my cutters have more scratches than the one in your photo. A black Ark won't remove them, in fact I'm sure it actually causes them. I don't believe them to be of any real consequence at all. File it under I'm probably better off not looking at my cutters through a microscope. Like a tiny insignificant insect, they look like horrific monsters/Marianas trench (as it applies) under magnification.

I'm sure if I loaded the cutter in your photograph, even sans the back bevel and with those very tiny scratches, I would find it to be blistering sharp and more than up to snuff.

Maybe I'm just easy to please.

Post Extras Print Post   Remind Me!     Notify Moderator

Entire thread
Subject Posted by Posted on
* A2 Sharpening Question Sparetime 07/20/12 01:31 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question RLMillard   07/26/12 11:27 AM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question jon003   07/23/12 02:20 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Steve Friedman   07/23/12 02:46 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question CStanford   07/25/12 10:56 AM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Steve Friedman   07/25/12 02:10 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Arch_E   07/26/12 06:56 AM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Steve Friedman   07/26/12 07:47 AM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Window Guy   07/26/12 06:53 AM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Steve Friedman   07/26/12 07:38 AM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Window Guy   07/27/12 07:47 AM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question sdbranam   07/31/12 05:59 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question CStanford   07/25/12 03:47 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Timberwolf   07/21/12 08:31 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Derek Cohen   07/22/12 01:46 AM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Sparetime   07/25/12 08:23 AM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question CStanford   07/25/12 11:03 AM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question nazard   07/25/12 01:59 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question CStanford   07/25/12 04:09 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question CStanford   07/21/12 07:14 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question jmcphail   07/21/12 07:20 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question CStanford   07/21/12 07:28 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question AHill   07/21/12 04:42 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question CStanford   07/22/12 08:00 AM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question AHill   07/23/12 11:01 AM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Derek Cohen   07/22/12 11:10 AM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question CStanford   07/22/12 12:24 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question mongo   07/20/12 08:12 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question closed for business   07/20/12 08:20 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question mongo   07/20/12 08:06 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question RonB1957   07/20/12 07:35 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Mike Brady   07/20/12 07:46 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Mtobey   07/20/12 02:39 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Mtobey   07/20/12 02:41 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Schtoo   07/20/12 09:27 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question jmcphail   07/21/12 12:28 AM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question CStanford   07/21/12 07:35 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Schtoo   07/22/12 09:42 AM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question CStanford   07/22/12 12:34 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Schtoo   07/22/12 07:19 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question CStanford   07/23/12 07:07 AM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Schtoo   07/23/12 08:09 AM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question CStanford   07/23/12 02:29 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question PaulC   07/23/12 10:37 AM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Blacky's BoyModerator   07/23/12 08:18 AM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Mtobey   07/23/12 11:11 AM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Timberwolf   07/23/12 09:11 AM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Schtoo   07/23/12 10:52 AM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Timberwolf   07/23/12 01:03 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Schtoo   07/23/12 01:11 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Timberwolf   07/23/12 01:20 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question AHill   07/23/12 01:56 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Mtobey   07/22/12 10:40 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Greg Jones   07/22/12 08:45 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Schtoo   07/22/12 10:44 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question sdbranam   07/22/12 09:27 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question tirebob   07/22/12 11:05 AM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Window Guy   07/22/12 02:49 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Schtoo   07/21/12 03:18 AM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question closed for business   07/21/12 06:44 AM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Mtobey   07/21/12 08:11 AM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Alan S   07/21/12 09:11 AM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Mtobey   07/21/12 09:54 AM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Mtobey   07/21/12 10:29 AM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Window Guy   07/21/12 02:33 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Mtobey   07/21/12 05:51 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Window Guy   07/22/12 06:40 AM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Aram   07/21/12 03:46 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Aram   07/20/12 02:17 PM
. * Re: A2 Sharpening Question Bibliophile 13Moderator   07/20/12 02:05 PM

Extra information
4 registered and 16 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  WoodNet Manager, Gene P, Vince, K. L, McReynolds, thooks, EightFingers, fivestring©™±, Joe Fisher, barnowl, Ruffturn®, meackerman, Bibliophile 13, Blacky's Boy, Grainraiser, blackhat 



Forum Permissions
      You cannot start new topics
      You cannot reply to topics
      HTML is disabled
      UBBCode is enabled

Thread views: 6286

Jump to

Contact Us | Contact the Moderators | Privacy Policy WoodNet Forums | WoodNet

*
UBB.threads™ 6.4.4