+- Woodnet Forums (https://www.forums.woodnet.net)
+-- Thread: CNC shark 2 any opinions (/showthread.php?tid=7350882)
CNC shark 2 any opinions - JDuke - 10-22-2019
There’s one for sale local to me
Asking price is $3000 which seems high but I might be interested if I could get it for a little less.
Are these decent usable machines?
How do they compare to the tablesaw spectrum
Are we talking they are as frustrating as a bench top saw,
Decent middle of the road like a used contractor saw?
I can’t imagine they would be as high on the spectrum of utility and functionality as a cabinet saw.
Any opinions?
Thanks in advance
Duke
RE: CNC shark 2 any opinions - Large Wooden Badger - 10-22-2019
I've had the black diamond edition now for 5 years or so. Works just fine. Admittedly I don't use it as much as I should, I got into hand tools so my projects have changed up some, but the kids like to make stuff on it.
RE: CNC shark 2 any opinions - Phil Thien - 10-22-2019
I'd take a Carbide 3D unit over any of the CNC Shark gear I've seen.
RE: CNC shark 2 any opinions - JDuke - 11-22-2019
Phil
I partially took your advice.
I found a shapeoko xl not the xxl semi local and got it for $800
No computer but does have router. Haven’t had a chance to hook it up yet.
But they also had a pirhana that I was able to pick up for $450
Also got the discs for bobcad v31 but without a key that will be virtually useless.
Now I need to get everything up and running
Any advice would be appreciated.
Duke
RE: CNC shark 2 any opinions - Arlin Eastman - 11-26-2019
(10-22-2019, 11:41 AM)JDuke Wrote: There’s one for sale local to me
Asking price is $3000 which seems high but I might be interested if I could get it for a little less.
Are these decent usable machines?
How do they compare to the tablesaw spectrum
Are we talking they are as frustrating as a bench top saw,
Decent middle of the road like a used contractor saw?
I can’t imagine they would be as high on the spectrum of utility and functionality as a cabinet saw.
Any opinions?
Thanks in advance
Duke
Duke
The Shark is nothing like a tablesaw it is a CNC cutting machine that either has a router attached or a buit in motor head and it is more like a carving machine than anything else.
https://www.woodcraft.com/products/shark-hd5-cnc-machine-next-wave-automation?gclid=Cj0KCQiAt_PuBRDcARIsAMNlBdrrlczFgPg5vJ6KZSGUWnnpulhm0bp-ixA68yjpcBDeIIyYDdj0IhQaAiNJEALw_wcB
https://www.woodcraft.com/products/cnc-shark-ii?gclid=Cj0KCQiAt_PuBRDcARIsAMNlBdo68XwRcruBvFiquJ6ox5hmPY6aSeMS-TTnCmwzmjiZ8yW6U5xagzQaAuDpEALw_wcB
Both have routers for the cutters. Also the bits are one of the most important thing for this for a lot of variable cutting and first is the software.
Also note the prices on both of them. Even if he has the $4k unit he is still asking to much and if he is selling the $3k unit he is asking for the same price as new.
If it is the first one I would say $2300 to $2500 if it is the second one than $1600 to $1900. Last he might have an older model then both of these and if that is the case take off anther $500 on the prices I said.
Do you have a link to what you are buying??
RE: CNC shark 2 any opinions - JDuke - 11-26-2019
Arlin
I am aware of the difference between a Cnc router and a tablesaw.
I was asking about whether the shark is an entry level machine the way a bench top saw is with many of the same trade offs in level of function.
As of now, I have a shapeoko XL and a Piranha XL.
And am interested in any pointers on what type of projects to use it for as well as any good forums to get ongoing ideas.
Thank you
Duke
RE: CNC shark 2 any opinions - Gary™ - 11-28-2019
I'd run away from that Shark. Too much old tech and proprietary stuff there. Phil gave you great advice on Carbide3D
Adding a Laser and Spindle to mine this Christmas
RE: CNC shark 2 any opinions - Gary™ - 11-28-2019
(11-26-2019, 01:16 PM)JDuke Wrote: And am interested in any pointers on what type of projects to use it for as well as any good forums to get ongoing ideas.
Thank you
Duke
Sign up for the Carbide3D Community site. You'll find a ton of help and ideas there. When you're ready I recommend moving to Vectric Vcarve Desktop design software and they have a great site too
RE: CNC shark 2 any opinions - EricU - 11-29-2019
about the tablesaw analogy, I'd say it's a pretty good one. You can do good work with a bench top tablesaw, and the same is true for a Shapoko. The Shapoko and similar CNC is certainly one of the cheapest ways to build a CNC, and it can have issues. Having said that, people are using them commercially and there is one guy on the Shapoko FB group that is making car parts out of aluminum with his. I feel like he would probably be happier with a cnc mill for that, but it's working for him.
RE: CNC shark 2 any opinions - JDuke - 11-30-2019
I had a CNC benchtop metal mill with Mach3 controller and just sold it earlier this year having never really made much with it due to the complexity of drawing in CAD transitioning to CAM then G code.
I have already made a few plaques with words engraved, and milled out several fleur de lis as exercise with the shapeoko.
My 14 y/o daughter has also shown interest and has worked with me on engraving a name in a board.
That’s already more in one week than 8-9 years, so I’d say the shapeoko is a success so far and with slow feed rates, it’s surprisingly accurate.
Duke