+- Woodnet Forums (https://www.forums.woodnet.net)
+-- Thread: Interesting Pop Woodworking article (/showthread.php?tid=7156164)
Pages:
1
2
Interesting Pop Woodworking article - jussi - 12-01-2015
Check out Megan Fitzpatrick's article titled "Shop-made Sandpaper" page 10. In it she kind of pokes fun at people who restore old tools or builds their own. Alot of this was probably meant to be sarcastic and in jest but I'm not sure it translated very well. Strange article, especially for the editor, to write in a mag where many of their readers probably rehab and/or make their own tools.
Re: Interesting Pop Woodworking article - Acorn - 12-01-2015
I subscribe to PW so this doesn't particularly apply to me, but distributing this PDF to the entire WoodNet forums group is probably not kosher.
Just sayin'
Re: Interesting Pop Woodworking article - jussi - 12-01-2015
True. I saw the link on another forum and wasn't thinking and just reposted it. I deleted the link.
Re: Interesting Pop Woodworking article - joemac - 12-01-2015
It was obviously meant in humor. If that humor isn't funny to you, so be it. Nonetheless I am certain that Megan never intended to show a lack of respect for the rehabbers, as she is rehabbing an older home she purchased and has rehabbed quite a bit of old furniture. I saw it as a tongue in cheek article and nothing more.
She is a lot smarter and much classier than to throw stones at the industry that puts bread on her table and gives her so much personal enjoyment.
My 2 cents worth and not intended as a flame.
Re: Interesting Pop Woodworking article - John Clifford - 12-01-2015
joemac said:
It was obviously meant in humor. If that humor isn't funny to you, so be it. Nonetheless I am certain that Megan never intended to show a lack of respect for the rehabbers, as she is rehabbing an older home she purchased and has rehabbed quite a bit of old furniture. I saw it as a tongue in cheek article and nothing more.
She is a lot smarter and much classier than to throw stones at the industry that puts bread on her table and gives her so much personal enjoyment.
My 2 cents worth and not intended as a flame.
QFT
Re: Interesting Pop Woodworking article - clydeone - 12-01-2015
I know I will likely offend someone with this post
Re: Interesting Pop Woodworking article - ronkan - 12-01-2015
Megan's writing often has a quirky bend to it. It usually works well for me, but clearly not for everyone. No flame intended.
The title of the article, Shop-made Sandpaper, should be the first clue. Even the most dedicated DIYer, maker of his own tools Neander would be highly unlikely to want to build his or her own sandpaper.
But if I decide to make some sandpaper, where can I get different grits of sand?
An attempt at a little levity is always welcome even if it sometimes isn't real successful.
Re: Interesting Pop Woodworking article - rkwoodwork - 12-01-2015
I am not offended. Nevertheless it was a crappy editorial, kind of a waste of bandwidth.
Re: Interesting Pop Woodworking article - Daniel S - 12-01-2015
I thought that the article was really funny. There are always things that others do that make sense for them, but not someone else. Lot's of people have a strong opinion of their chosen path.
Re: Interesting Pop Woodworking article - Bill_Houghton - 12-01-2015
Hey - she's a Shakespearean scholar - her humor's likely to tend toward the strong flavors, from reading all those plays of Will's.
I haven't read it yet; still working my way through a backlog of magazines.